Hello,
On Fri, Sep 30, 2022 at 05:18:21PM +0100, Chris Wallace via BitFolk Users wrote:
name@mydomain is redirected to kit.wallace(a)gmail.com
so I'm not sure gmail
is even looking at mydomain's DNS record anyway
This isn't the problem you are seeing here, but in general you are
going to have a bad time forwarding email into gmail. The reason why
is that a lot of email won't have DKIM signatures but will have SPF
set for its envelope sending domain. So, when you forward a mail in
to gmail, Google will check the SPF record of the envelope sending
domain against your IP address, which will fail, and Google will
reject it.
If you are going to forward mail into gmail you pretty much have to
rewrite the envelope sender to be your own domain, so that your own
SPF record is checked. That's typically done with SRS.
Then you have a different problem in that you absolutely have to
make sure you don't forward any spam in to gmail as after SRS any
spam will then be marked against the reputation of your domain.
All in all, forwarding mail into gmail is highly problematic.
Again, this isn't the problem you are seeing here as you said that
the email that was rejected was from your domain, not from some
other domain, so there is something about your SPF record that
Google doesn't like. Perhaps it had cached your old record though?
Cheers,
Andy
--
https://bitfolk.com/ -- No-nonsense VPS hosting